Showing posts with label nonprofits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nonprofits. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

In the Business of Transformation

“Many managers and executives are voicing their fears that the talent they have is not the talent they need,” states Jean B. Leslie, manager of product development research at the Center for Creative Leadership in Greensboro, N.C. “Businesses, government agencies, nonprofits and educational organizations need leaders who can effectively navigate complex, changing situations and get the job done. The questions that need to be asked at the organizational level are: who do we have, what do they need to do and are they equipped to do it?”  The Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina has taken on the task of answering these questions.

Current leadership skill gaps, as well as fears of gaps for the future, present opportunities and creative space to examine positive leadership and the processes by which strong, authentic and highly-skilled leaders are developed. It is critical that a new generation of positive leaders is prepared to lead in the 21st century and beyond. To facilitate this, we must provide leaders with the knowledge and skills needed to fill the leadership gaps for current leaders and to diminish fears regarding what emerging leaders are able to offer for the future.

 In the fall of 2010, a partnership with the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina’s Carolina Academy for Nonprofits and Columbia College was formed. As a result of the partnership, a graduate level Nonprofit Leadership Training Certificate program was developed and implemented. Following the inaugural year of the certificate program, a Nonprofit Leadership Development Program was created. Both leadership programs were designed for nonprofit leaders who were recognized as having great potential and who were ready to enhance their knowledge, skills and framework to lead nonprofit organizations in an ever-changing and diverse society.

Now after three cohorts of leadership certificate graduates and one cohort of leadership development graduates, The Foundation’s Carolina Academy for Nonprofits has become a leader in courageously charting a course of leadership education for nonprofit organizations in South Carolina. To date, 30 nonprofit leaders have emerged with greater knowledge, more confidence and increased capacity to lead in his/her organization. One graduate stated,
My experience as an Academy student has equipped me with an array of information, tools, and knowledge. I have gained a deepened understanding of, and appreciation for, interacting with agency stakeholders including co-workers, staff, administrators/board members, funders and other external partners. Establishing a set of best practices that can be used to improve agency processes has supported my goal of enhancing project design, implementation and partnerships. Most importantly, my Academy participation helped me to find my voice, and valuing the significance it brings. As a result, my passion has been reignited to improve the lives of my constituency.
As we begin our 2012-2013 cohorts of students, we do so with a certainty that we are doing our part to continue to answer the questions, “who do we have, what do they need to do and are they equipped to do it?” We are in the business of transformation and we are doing it one leader at a time.

Katrina Spigner is the senior program officer at the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Looking at Poverty Differently


One often wonders about how to best serve the poor and marginalized in our communities. We wonder whether we are maximizing our resources to have lasting results. Recently, I met “Toxic Charity” author Robert Lupton at a meeting in Myrtle Beach, S.C. Lupton shed tremendous light on some of the concerns around serving the poor.  

At the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina, we recognize a distinct separation between generational poverty and situational poverty, and how we address them both. We view generational poverty as chronic, with many variables that have caused a person to live in poverty, including family structure, community structure, educational attainment, access to health care, life skills, culture, value and attitudes. We view situational poverty as crisis poverty. A person is without food, clothing or shelter or in need of medical attention now but has no health insurance coverage.  These two distinctions are very apparent and both are worthy of the Foundation’s attention and resources. In the Foundation’s case, more than 85% of our grant funding goes to addressing generational poverty. We feel we have greater impact in South Carolina addressing generational poverty, but we also realize that situational and crisis poverty exists and needs support.

Lupton explained the dilemma faced with providing services through our government, churches and nonprofit organizations. Lupton believes, and I agree, that we often apply crisis tactics to chronic problems, even when the situation is clearly persistent. Applying crisis intervention to a chronic issue can be harmful to a person or a family and it fosters dependency, which perpetuates poverty. This is why people who are poor remain poor.

The question becomes “what can we do differently?” Lupton feels the most important factor missing in most service programs for the poor is that the recipient has no “skin in the game.” You give them something the first time and they appreciate it. You give them something a second time and they anticipate it. You give them something a third time and they expect it. You give it a fourth time and they depend on it. If you really look closely at a person in poverty, odds are that they would much rather be a partner or participant than a charity case.  That is why free clothes closets are not good but thrift stores work. That is why free food banks foster dependency but inexpensive food co-ops allow the person to become a customer.

A lot of organizations are trying very hard to do the right thing for others. This is in no way to criticize the good intentions that organizations have or the work that they do. This is about looking at those we want to help, differently. This is about respecting the client and building their ability to be self sufficient. As Lupton said, “We never do for someone else what they are capable of doing for themselves.”

Communities and organizations dealing with issues around poverty must be willing to shift. The United States gives away more food, money and services than any other country in the world. But rather than just giving it away, can we find new ways to partner or help individuals become more independent? If so, they will become respected and confident consumers with a greater sense of self worth. It will also create an environment where individuals are no longer viewed as “charity” and where chronic issues are addressed more strategically and more collegially.

These kinds of changes will have a positive impact on the entire community. I invite you to read Lupton’s book, “Toxic Charity: HowChurches and Charities Hurt Those They Help (And How to Reverse It).” It will change the way you look at those you are trying to help. It sure makes sense to me. 


Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina



Note: Learn how one Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina grantee puts Lupton's thoughts into practice. Reverend Bill Stanfield, co-founder and chief executive officer of the Metanoia Community Development Corporation of North Charleston, shared a first-hand example of how to build a strong community using the strengths of the community rather than the deficiencies.

Friday, March 18, 2011

The True Reality of Grantmaking Today

Today’s demand for philanthropic dollars is chaotic.  The need for resources is overwhelming and it is affecting both large and small nonprofits. Many non-profits believe that foundations such as the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina are going to be the “quick fix” to their current financial challenges. Unfortunately, it does not work that way.

Most foundations move very deliberately and purposefully. They don’t make quick decisions nor do they “knee jerk” to crisis needs. The one common denominator is that foundations do have dollars to spend and nonprofits need dollars to spend. Other than that, every foundation has a different set of giving principles, goals and desired outcomes. Often times, an organization will apply for and expect funding from a foundation simply because the organization has a similar mission to the foundation’s mission. But more and more, foundations are looking “inward” at what they want to accomplish, than looking “outward” at what others want or need to accomplish.

In other words, foundations are becoming more intentional about their grant giving. Foundations have their own set of indicators that determine whether or not they are successful or meeting their own mission. Sometimes it aligns with a nonprofit and sometimes it doesn’t. For example, the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina has limited resources which force us to make extremely difficult decisions about how and where the Foundation does its social investing. It is just the way it is. Equipping families with the resources to live out of poverty is ambitious and a very difficult hill for us to climb. It is our goal to have the greatest impact on reducing poverty, mostly through addressing causes rather than consequences. That is not to say that we don’t invest in consequences but it is not our priority. We are going to dig deeper and invest more strategically to influence change that defines who we are and the goals and outcomes we, as a funder, must achieve.
 
This may require fewer grants to fewer organizations but the organizations that are funded will clearly align with our mission, focus, desired outcomes and key indicators. We will be looking for more defined partners to help us meet our goals. It is the only way we can be truly effective and measure the changes we are able to affect in poor communities and neighborhoods. Some funds will continue to be directed towards meeting basic needs. A lot of individuals and families are struggling and we cannot, in good conscience, ignore that. However, true change in the lives of those living in generational poverty will require more of our attention and resources as we move “further upstream” to find the answers and create greater impact.

Our hope is that future consequences of poverty will be less severe because needed prevention, intervention, learning, skill building and life style changes have occurred on the front end.  There is no doubt that many nonprofit organizations are trying to do good work in communities across South Carolina. Unfortunately, we can only choose a few and align with them to further our goals and mission of lifting families out of poverty.

Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Funding Shortfalls Continue to Challenge Us All

Funding shortfalls from government and the private sector continue to negatively impact South Carolina’s nonprofits. Organizations that previously seemed impervious to the economic downturn are now suffering tremendously. Nonprofits are cutting staff and programs and simply doing whatever is necessary to keep the doors open. The sad news is there is no immediate resolution on the horizon.

The reality is that organizations must operate using a scaled-down model. In some cases, nonprofits have reduced their staff by 50%, yet the demand for the services they provide has increased. Foundations must also be willing to change with the times. For example, the Sisters of Charity Foundation is funding operational expenses for nonprofits. This is something we did not consider for many years. To allow more organizations to apply for our Caritas Grants program, which are grants that meet basic needs, we have raised the operating budget limit for potential applicants. In an effort to be grantee-friendly, the Foundation is lifting a process that has been in place. If an organization is funded in one year, they can now apply for a grant the following year. Previously, a full year had to expire before this was possible, and often grantseekers were forced to wait nearly a year and a half to reapply for funding. Additionally, the Foundation is looking at providing restructuring and reorganization grants to allow nonprofits to look at new models, mergers and even dissolution. 

 
The fact is that our Foundation funds are tight. This is the smallest budget we have ever had in our 15-year history. We cannot let this stop us from reaching as many nonprofits as possible. We will have three grant cycles in 2011 and, along with our initiative funding, we will award more than $2.4 million across South Carolina. In addition to grantmaking, the Foundation will provide multiple learning opportunities and training sessions for nonprofits to attend free of charge. A current list is updated regularly on our Web site. These free sessions are geared towards helping organizations find ways to be more successful and to operate more efficiently. The programs will be available in Columbia, S.C., at the Foundation office as well as other locations in the state. So even though times are extremely challenging, there are still many opportunities.


Success may be measured differently this year. Our success will be measured by how many organizations we can assist and therefore, how many individuals and families living in poverty we can help.  It is my hope that every organization operating will find a way to garner the resources they need to operate necessary programs this year. Otherwise, needy individuals and families will continue to suffer and bear a large part of the brunt of these tough economic times.







Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

2011 Tips for Nonprofits

As we embark on a new year with new goals, I want to offer a few “low cost” tips to our grantees and other nonprofit practitioners that can pay dividends for you. They are:

• Strengthen Your Boards- The staff can only do so much. If you find and recruit new board members that can be passionate about your organization and help you raise money, then you will be in a much better place by the end of the year. New board members can open doors and help you access and raise new dollars.

 
• Embrace Social Media- Today’s world requires immediate and up to date information. A stale Web site and a printed newsletter distributed a few times a year is not enough. You are missing opportunities to market yourself and let the larger community know what is happening with your organization. If you haven’t already done so, then start a Facebook page, connect your organization on LinkedIn, tweet on Twitter, create an electronic newsletter and begin to write a blog. All of these tools are essentially free. It is just a matter of taking the time to learn and implement. There are plenty of people that are knowledgeable about social media that would be willing to assist you. 

 
• Get in front of the Public- Clubs, organizations and business groups often meet every week. They are always looking for speakers. Make an effort to develop a presentation that you, your staff and your volunteers can use. Then make the contacts with Rotary, Kiwanis, Lion’s, Civitan, Chambers of Commerce, VFW’s, American Legion and many other clubs and ask them to get on the calendar for a presentation about your organizations. Many professional associations allot part of their meetings for presentations from nonprofits. Only good things can happen from these efforts. People will learn more about your organization and they may be willing to volunteer and even donate, once they are informed.

 
• Be Efficient- Spend wisely. Seek “in-kind” services. Some company may not give you money but they might print a brochure for free. In my former fund raising life, I asked a bank for a financial donation. They said no but they offered me five billboards for a three-month period all over town. They put me in touch with their ad agency and the agency donated the cost to prepare the billboard. Because the bank was such a good customer, the billboard company put the five signs up for free. We had free advertising for three months at no cost to our organization. 

 
• Network- We can all learn something from each other. When you attend a workshop or conference, make sure you walk away from the event with at least one new contact and, hopefully, at least one new idea.  If someone is doing something that is working, there is no reason it can’t work for you. It is worth a try.

 
• Be Willing to Change- Often times, we get use to doing things a certain way. We get stuck in our own organizational mindset. Be willing to welcome change. Look for new ways to grow and improve your organization and yourself. If the old model is not working, then change course. If your ideas are no longer enough, then find new ideas by learning from other people. It can only help your organization move forward progressively and positively and that is what you want.

 
There are no easy solutions to complex problems in today’s nonprofit world. Many times cost prohibits us from accomplishing certain goals. However, there are other ways to grow and succeed that do not cost anything other than your time and energy. I encourage you to consider these “tips” as you move forward in 2011. Remember the old adage “Nothing ventured; nothing gained.” Now is your opportunity to try a few new things that will, hopefully, bring positive results and at little or no expense.




Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Leadership Grads are a Special Group

Our first leadership class graduated last week at a special ceremony at Columbia College. There were nine individuals that went through the year long program. The participants were exposed to an array of topics, top notch lecturers, robust discussions and, yes, a fair amount of homework to complete.

These individuals (8 women and 1 man) made a lot of sacrifices to accomplish the goal of attaining a certificate in nonprofit leadership and nine hours of graduate level credit from Columbia College. They met every month for a year and they did this all while working a full-time job and managing all the other responsibilities they have in their lives. I was impressed.

At the ceremony, I saw family members, lecturers, mentors and friends come and celebrate the success of these individuals.  There was a feeling of pride in that room that really was contagious. The chosen class speaker, Beck Sullivan, did an extraordinary job with her speech. She represented the class members so well.  These leaders will go back to work better prepared for the many challenges they face on a daily basis. They will also be poised to address long-range organizational direction and plans which are often hard to do when you are dealing with the day to day minutia.

The other thing I really witnessed in this inaugural year was the bonding that occurred among the nonprofit leaders. They have grown to love and respect each other. They have learned about family and work challenges and feel a part of each other’s lives. More importantly, they have learned a lot of useful and practical information from each other during this one year period. They have learned what works well and what does not. They have learned to be flexible and to think differently than before. They have, indeed, become better leaders.

In the end, we were all proud. We are proud of the individual accomplishments, we are proud of our Foundation team for orchestrating the program. We are proud of Columbia College and their wonderful commitment to the program and we are proud of the overall concept and how it went from a crumpled sheet of paper in 2007 to our first graduation in 2010. 

The second class comes into get started this week. If they are half as passionate and committed as the first class, I will be happy. I can’t wait to see them and I can’t wait to watch them grow and bond.

Pictured from left to right: Laurie Hopkins, Ph.D. (Columbia College), Vanassa Frazier (Christ Teens), Cecilia Meggs (Lighthouse Ministries), Betsy Marlow (Miss Ruby’s Kids), Preston Winkler (Greater Columbia Community Relations Council), Dorothy Priester (Cherokee County First Steps), Beck Sullivan (Municipal Association of South Carolina), Lila Anna Sauls (St. Lawrence Place), Tom Keith (Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina) and Katrina Spigner (Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina) at the August 6, 2010, graduation.

 Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

Building a presence on Web 2.0; How the Foundation embraced social media and why you should too


It is likely you’ve heard of Web sites like Myspace, Facebook and YouTube. These types of tools, referred to as social media or Web 2.0, allow individuals and organizations to shift fluidly and flexibly between the roles of audience and author. By integrating technology, social interaction and words and images, social media allows people to share opinions, insights, experiences and perspectives with each other.

The types of social media are broad and are still being created, which may cause those unfamiliar with the tools to be overwhelmed by the possibilities. But the key to understanding all social media is that it is the great leveler where users no longer just take in information that is supplied to them, but interact with that information, rate it and upload their own.

Social networking sites have received a lot of attention from the nonprofit world because they align with nonprofits' desire to reach out to larger communities. What’s more, most sites are free, making them an economical choice for effective marketing. When deciding whether or not to participate in social media, there are a few things to consider.

Audiences have shifted online. Consumers are taking control of how, what and where they access information. According to Neilson, in June 2010 three of the world’s most popular online brands are social media related: Facebook, YouTube and Wikipedia, and the average visitor spends 66% more time on these sites than a year ago (6 hours in April 2010 versus 3 hours, 31 minutes last year).
                            
There are more than 100 million unique impressions delivered on networks like Myspace and Facebook per month. Facebook added its 500-millionth member this year. The site now has users on every continent, with half of them logging in at least once a day. Chances are people are already online talking about you; join them.

It is a good way to build support, build your database and promote specific actions, like donating to a cause, writing your congressman on an issue or attending an event. Once you connect with a contact, friend or fan, you are also connected to their list of contacts and friends, and their contacts and friends. Essentially, you are accessing the means of exponential growth as 10 of your contacts connect with 10 contacts (10x10=100) and then 10 more contacts (10X100=1,000). For those organizations that do not have a Web site, it is an easy way to establish a simple and fluid web presence. 

For a better perspective, check out this video on the social media revolution.

Web 2.0 replaces the idea of a Web site as a static brochure on the internet and instead transforms your Web site into a community in which you can share your voice, your vision and your brand. It does have the potential to reach new people, including new donors or supporters of your organization.

It is, however, a conversation and if you are not committed to upholding your end of the conversation, then it doesn’t make sense to launch into social media. It requires regular maintenance and updating in order to keep the content fresh and attractive to visitors.

The Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina embraces social media with this blog and through a presence on LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter. The Foundation began publishing this blog in 2008. Through the blog, the Foundation shares thoughts and news on the Foundation, philanthropy and the plight of poverty in South Carolina.

The Foundation has a profile on LinkedIn, a professional networking site, and a Facebook page. The Foundation also uses Twitter to send 140 character updates, called tweets, to its followers which include legislators, nonprofit and community leaders and media outlets. It is another way for the Foundation to continue to build awareness, network and share its impact. While the current followers may not reach the masses, these tools have led to stories about the Foundation on other organizations’ Web sites, blogs and electronic newsletters.

Despite all of the trends and excitement around social media, many organizations struggle with getting executive buy-in to social media strategies. If there is difficulty in getting understanding and buy-in, discuss social media in the context of the mission of the organization and how it can help achieve the organizations goals, rather than the new and cool factor of the tools.

Conduct internet searches and see what is currently out there about your organization. If there is negative information or worse, no information, show the appropriate persons and have a social media plan to combat current online content and spread your organization’s message. Better yet, see what the competition is doing. Are they reaching audiences and participating in social media? Is your organization left behind?

Recommend more than one platform. If top executives can’t grasp the benefit of YouTube, offer another platform and encourage participation.

Lastly, provide examples of success stories from organizations using social media. In the Society for New Communications 2008 report titled “New Media, New Influencers & Implications for Public Relations” the Mayo Clinic notes that by launching a podcast campaign to share the stories of its customers and advocates and knowledge of its experts, the Clinic significantly increased traffic to its Web site and enhanced its influence.

Another case study in the same report focuses on the American Red Cross and the aftermath of the effects of social media following the Hurricane Katrina disaster in 2005. At that time the American Red Cross was not participating in social media and was unprepared to respond to the criticisms online, much of it incorrect and misinformation. The Red Cross now has a disaster portal where it creates all of its disaster-focused RSS (syndication) feeds, a blog called Red Cross Chat, a Flickr community where people can share their photographs online and uses Twitter to update followers with alerts during a disaster.


Social media is timely and can influence action. For example, with the recent BP oil spill a Facebook Cause Page was set up called Help Wildlife Impacted by the BP Oil Spill and raised over $67,000 in a short time.

The importance of being social isn’t new. It builds understanding, fosters trust, develops relationships and can act as a catalyst for change. Social media does the same and allows organizations to expand their audience, discover others who share or support a similar interest and creates an online network of contacts and supporters. Go where the conversation is happening: What you give up in control you may gain in valuable information that you didn’t already know.


Brooke Bailey is the director of communications and public policy for the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

What Are We Thinking?

I was reminded recently of the “fine line” that we walk in philanthropy as it pertains to expectations of grantees. Also, we sometimes send mixed messages to those seeking funds. Let me explain. Two questions that most funders ask potential grantees are “what is your sustainability plan?” and “how do you intend to fund this project/program beyond this grant?” In isolation, these questions are relevant and fair. Foundation’s don’t want to fund something that is going to have a short life span and they don’t want to be “on the hook” for a long-term financial commitment to organizations they fund, thus the significance of these questions.

But what are the results in the relationship between grantee and funder if the grantee does or does not reach sustainability as the funder expects? Good question. Does the funder let the program die because they are unwilling to put up additional funding to get a program to sustainability even if it takes longer than expected? Another good question: do they walk away from a grantee that is a high achiever, reaches success with the grant funds and is sustained, but needs additional funding to take the program further?
Here is what I think? Funders, in large part, are fundamentally unrealistic about their expectations around sustainability. That is not to say that the questions should not be asked, but the reality is that nine times out of ten an organization is not going to be able to answer that question with certainty that they will or will not be able to sustain themselves following the grant award period. There are just too many variables that make the answers to the questions unachievable unless there is a funding stream that is ongoing, which is not the case for most nonprofits. Individual and corporate donors come and go, grant funding has a short life, special events take time and energy and wills and bequests happen infrequently.

Yes, foundations must be good stewards of their resources and they must operate within certain guidelines to be fair and accountable. But arbitrary time limits for grant funding and high expectations for sustainability is not helping, but rather hurting the very nonprofits that funders intend to help. So, if funders truly want to get the biggest bang for their buck then they need to consider some flexibility in decision-making and more realistic expectations around results, particularly as it applies to sustainability. During this economy, more nonprofits are fighting to survive than ever before. We, in the foundation business are investors; investors during good times and bad times. If we want a realistic return on that investment then we need to employ some alternative investment strategies. These include: a longer commitment for funding, more flexibility for those who can’t promise sustainability and let’s not punish those who have sustained themselves either.

The goal for nonprofits is to succeed with their mission and survive this difficult economy. We, in philanthropy, should not be obstacles toward achieving those goals but a catalyst for reaching those goals. This starts with a little self reflection about our processes and procedures, expectations and, yes, the questions we ask. If we can do that, then more realistic outcomes can be attained and our relationship with grantees will be stronger because they will know that we understand them better.



Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Understanding Who We Are; It's Complicated

The word “philanthropy” can have a different meaning depending on where you live and what a particular foundation looks like, which some believe is the biggest problem with philanthropy today. Philanthropy seems often self-indulged and not truly committed to finding new and innovative ways to address social problems at the grassroots level. I will also suggest that some funders I have met over the years have developed a cavalier attitude when it comes to their foundation’s direction and purpose. In their minds, they know what’s best for their community and it’s certainly their money to invest how and where they want.

Furthermore, we, as funders, have lofty expectations of those we fund and often apply a set of rules and expectations that are more about process and procedure instead of quality, content or community change. I deplore bureaucracies that force potential grantees to jump through enormous hoops just to get their application reviewed. We need to be spending more time and energy not setting up superfluous rules and guidelines but rather looking for more effective ways to engage and understand disadvantaged individuals and families. It makes far more sense to invest our resources in better defining the significant challenges facing those living in poverty along with understanding what their specific priorities are so they can live more productive lives. We also need their ongoing thoughts and input so our foundations’ decision making is grounded in real life issues and awareness.

Social change, to me, is far less about money and far more about attitude, clarity of purpose, influence and education. We often get caught in the money trap but, quite frankly, private philanthropy’s wealth is simply “a drop in the bucket” compared to the societal needs for underserved communities today.

More involvement and input from those we want to help is at the top of our list at the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina. It has to be. If not, we are making decisions in a vacuum that may be well-intended but often end up leaving important stakeholders out of the equation. I am not just talking about agency input but individual “client” input: the homeless, clients of the food banks, the unemployed, the children of single parents, students in poor school districts, families without access to health care, seniors without transportation, etc. It is a simple concept but it is also a fundamental shift for philanthropy. It is like asking a patient, “Where do you hurt?” rather than coming up with a diagnosis based on what you, the doctor, observes and thinks.


The true measure of social change will be viewed through many different lenses and measured differently by people in the field. However, significant change starts from the ground floor and works up; in the classroom, waiting in line for food or shelter, teen parenting, father absence, etc. Let’s not focus our energy solely on the process but rather on understanding and responding to those who really know how they feel. It is the right prescription for today’s philanthropic ills.


Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

This time in January, is a time of celebration, a time of recognition and a time of reflection. We celebrate the life of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. A man who changed the world while he was alive and his words and actions have helped change the world since his death.

We don’t have to necessarily be religious to appreciate Dr. King’s teachings. Now there is no question that his thoughts and words are grounded in his faith. One of the things that I have learned through hearing and reading Dr. King’s words is an ongoing message of encouragement. He was able to take people that felt hopeless and give them hope. He was not a man of violence but he was willing to stand firm on his beliefs of what was just and what was fair and what was equal, and then suffer the consequences of that action.

I recently visited the Lorraine Hotel in Memphis where Dr. King was assassinated. It was a surreal experience for me. The hotel has been made into a shrine for him but also for others who were willing to stand up for civil rights and for fairness. I stood in a replica of the bus where Rosa Parks refused to move. I saw pictures and signs of people who had been made to feel less than equal. Signs that pointed one color of skin to one bathroom and another color of skin to a different bathroom. Signs that allowed one color to sit in the main viewing area of a movie theatre and a sign that said if your skin was a certain color, then you must go up into the balcony away from others.

It gave me perspective and it continues to give me empathy and understanding.

It has been over 40 years since Dr. Martin Luther King was killed in Memphis. And, as I prepared this piece, I asked myself two questions: What has not changed and what has changed since Dr. King’s death?

First, what has not changed:

  • Our public education system in poor communities in South Carolina still ranks near the bottom in the United States. It ranks near the bottom in qualified and competent teachers, in student performance and―first and foremost―in funds available to support those teachers and students. Our future generation of young people will have significant limitations unless we make education a priority in our state, and not just in the wealthy communities, but all communities. In the lawsuit waged between the Corridor of Shame Counties and the State of South Carolina, a small bit of progress was made but overall I was ashamed of our state’s response. Do you mean to tell me that you can be satisfied that we are offering our young people in poor counties a minimally adequate education. All this occurring in buildings that were built over 100 years ago without proper heat, plumbing or other basic necessities. I believe that very little progress has been made in our public educational system in poor communities in the last 40 years.
  • Health care. I cannot tell you how disappointed I am with the state of health care, health access and health coverage in this country. It is a colossal problem that we continue to ignore and our leaders continue to base their decisions on the influence of big insurance companies and drug companies. Every single person in this country should be entitled to health care and not have to put themselves or their families at risk because of it. We must have a system in place that emphasizes prevention, easy access to providers and ongoing treatment and coverage regardless of the age or financial position a person finds themselves in.

  • Jobs. There is such a disparity in jobs between the haves and the have nots that it is almost comical. We continue to provide minimal opportunities for education and therefore hamstring our poorer populations to do basic jobs that do not afford them growth or to realistically take care of their families. We must embrace and push job training and create job opportunities for the poor. If not, we are contributing to a systemic problem that fosters dependency on government with very few options otherwise. We say we have a free market society but it is not a free market for those that don’t have the education or resources to truly participate. There is a serious imbalance that needs to be addressed.
To my second question, What has changed:

I would say that we have more people invested than ever before. We had a national movement that elected Barack Obama President. We have more people volunteering in our nonprofit sector than ever before. We have after school tutoring programs, job training programs, nursing programs in rural areas, fatherhood programs, access to justice initiatives and leadership development programs for our youth.

I have seen progress. Is it world-changing progress? No, but it is progress.

We, living and working in communities, have the same opportunities to make a difference or invest in change that Dr. Martin Luther King had more than 40 years ago. We see the injustices in education, health care and jobs. We, in the private sector, can help and are helping.

South Carolina has its problems but so does every other state in our country. If South Carolina is going to succeed, then every one of its citizens must have an opportunity to succeed. If South Carolina is going to improve then racial divides must be broken and our state must look at each other as fellow South Carolinians with common purpose and pride.

If Dr. King were alive today, I think he would be disappointed in a lot of things. I also believe he would be proud of a lot of things. He would be proud of our spirit. He would be proud of our willingness to find new ways to help others and he would be proud that we, as private citizens, are willing and able to take ownership in the needed changes in our state and communities and help lead that charge.

So, I challenge each of you today to not live in a world that is secure and privileged but live in a world that is sensitive and empathetic. Don’t just watch as things occur but participate. Don’t just care but act. Don’t just breathe life but live life. The outcome may seem simple but it could be monumental. Wouldn’t it be wonderful that after all is said and done, we could look at our fellow citizens and friends; black, white, Christian or non-Christian, democrat or republican, male or female, rich or poor and we can say, “Job well done, my neighbor and friend, job well done.”

God bless you all.

Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Thinking About the Year End

As we approach the end of the calendar year, there is hopefulness among charitable organizations that something good is going to happen. There is a hope that people will feel more benevolent during the holiday season and give money. They recognize that the first 11 months of 2009 have been far less successful than anticipated. Organizations are “holding out hope” that this final month of the year will “pay off” financially. Additional optimism occurs when charities think about donors who need a tax break and will give generously to their organization.

What a wonderful fantasy they are having. I don’t think there is much chance this will happen in December 2009. Why? Well, most people are either struggling to make ends meet (average incomes), need assistance from others to survive (below average incomes) or lost 55% of their portfolio in the stock market (higher incomes). Those who lost money are trying to recover those funds and are worried about their own future retirement possibilities. Any of these three scenarios does not bode well for charities this year end.


The good news; I believe, that 2010 will be a far better year for all charities. I truly believe we have weathered a very tough storm and that we can begin repairing our organizations next year. Charitable giving will improve in 2010 and it will improve in the business, grant making and individual/private sectors.
So, don’t expect a huge windfall in December, it likely won’t come. Do expect more funds and better circumstances for all of next year. I really think help from generous supporters is just around the corner and better times are ahead for charities.

Happy Holidays to All.


Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Friday, October 2, 2009

Let's be Realistic about Expenses for Nonprofits

I often talk to nonprofit organizations about the fact that they are all being held to a higher standard and rightfully so. They are dealing with funds that have been entrusted to them by a cadre of donors that have invested in their organization’s work. Along with that are certain standards and expectations that require a nonprofit to not only succeed in accomplishing their mission, but to succeed with extreme efficiency. My question becomes, “Is this a realistic expectation in today’s tough economy, where dollars are very hard to come by?”

The standard I am speaking about is the long established 20/80 ratio where no more than 20% of a dollar should go for fund raising, management and administrative costs and no less than 80% should go for programs and related services. In a perfect world, these are ambitious numbers and certainly demonstrate the kind of efficiencies we want and expect from a nonprofit organization. However, when times are tough and dollars are hard to come by, it may require organizations to spend more on infrastructure because they have less money to work with. In other words, keeping a program director in place to deliver services to children or keeping your bookkeeper in place to manage your systems more efficiently are necessary but may hold your costs higher and, therefore, outside the normal 20/80 ratio.

I understand this completely and I ask that we reconsider this expectation and as a fair comprise, perhaps, look at it on a three year or five year average basis. It is not unusual that ‘for profit” businesses, which are in business to make money, operate on much thinner margins and with less profit. Some grocery store chains are extremely pleased when they hit a 95/5 ratio at the end of the month. Yes, that means 95% cost to make a 5% profit.

So right now, I don’t think it is unreasonable at all to allow nonprofits to have a 30/70 or even 35/65 ratio with operating costs to program costs. We need to be sensitive and flexible with the rules at this time. I am all for accountability and efficiently run organizations but I am also a realist when it comes to making sure services are delivered by a competent and dedicated staff, recognizing that most of these organizations are being run by underpaid and overworked people. Now is the time for us to help organizations succeed and to also be pragmatic about what we expect. I truly believe the next few years will be extremely tough on the nonprofit sector and, therefore, I am willing to cut them some slack when it comes to costs. It may be the only way organizations can survive, can get the job done and get their mission accomplished and we very much need to be in tune with that situation.


Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Foundations Can’t Live in a Vacuum

Philanthropy is often perceived as the all knowing, all deciding sector that can really change the world through strategic decision making and private funding. Foundations have high expectations of grantees including measurable outcomes and the desire for a realistic sustainability plan. However, I am not sure foundations do a good enough job of really surveying the landscape and understanding the depth and breadth of the nonprofit community and, more specifically, the organizations they fund.

Do we really know what other funders are doing for an organization that we fund and do those funds compliment what we are funding or does it work in contrast to what we are funding? It is a deeper question than most foundations won’t necessarily want to tackle, but I believe it is an important one. As an investor in the nonprofit world, we must do everything within our power to protect our investment, clearly understand the pathology of the organization we are invested in and measure our success to insure our investment is providing the return that we expect and deserve.

Long gone are the days when foundations could put money out in the community with the hope that something good happened. With the tough economy and dwindling resources, we are forced to be more focused and intentional with our grants and decision making. This has never been more apparent to me than now as we work on the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina’s Strategic Plan for the future. It requires us to maximize and leverage our funds, have a knowledge based approach to decision making and information sharing and it requires us to do a smaller number of things well. It did not have to be that way ten years ago but it has to be that way today.

Part of the equation is to have our own plan and strategies in place to insure that we know where we are going, but we must also understand the plan and strategies of our nonprofit partners. Where are they going? Do they have the resources to get there? Do they have the infrastructure to take them there? Are we on the same page as other funders or are the investments totally different and possibly contributing to the nonprofit’s organizational schizophrenia?

Our recent hiring of a full time senior research and evaluation director should tell you a lot about where we are headed. Success and failure are measured all the time. It is measured in the classroom, board room, ball fields and in our own personal performance evaluations. We, as a Foundation, are going to measure it more and understand it better. But, we should not live in a vacuum. We must also understand our nonprofit partners and know where they are going and who is helping them get there. If not, we are merely exacerbating the problem and enabling organizational ambiguity. This is not the time for anyone to be doing that.



Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Foundations Must Strike Balance

Foundations must find a way to create balance during difficult economic times. It is without question that all foundation assets are down significantly since mid 2008. It was an unavoidable consequence of the U.S. economic downturn. Here is the dilemma. Should foundations spend into their corpus to maintain a consistent spending level when they know their assets have dropped by several million dollars? This is where the balance part comes into play.

Foundations have to spend into the corpus at some level but cannot afford to spend too much and, as a result, put the foundation’s long-term viability at risk. If a foundation is going to survive and thrive for decades to come, then it must be realistic and pragmatic about its funding decisions. On the other hand, nonprofit organizations cannot be left “high and dry.” Thus, foundations are finding creative ways to provide some funds─albeit reduced─and also provide other services to enhance the work of nonprofit organizations and their leaders. An example of these supplementary services is the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina Learning Academy’s leadership tract, offering nonprofit executive directors graduate-level training and credit in effective leadership strategies, and its forthcoming distance learning opportunities throughout the state.

Foundations have to partner too. The Sisters of Charity Foundation collaborates with the South Carolina Department of Social Services, University of South Carolina School of Medicine, Columbia College, Columbia Chamber of Commerce, United Way of the Midlands and the Central Carolina Community Foundation. The two latter partners and the Foundation are working to leverage a Bank of America grant to assist and address issues around the merging of struggling and failing nonprofits.

It is certain that our Foundation’s available grant funds will be less in 2010 than they were in 2009. However, through creativity and balance we plan to accomplish as much or more than ever next year. Through capacity building, listening sessions, knowledge sharing, distance learning opportunities, social media and other communications tools and more workshops for nonprofit staff and volunteers, we will make an impact next year. This is all in addition to the grant funds that we will still distribute. Though, fewer funds will force us to be more focused and have even higher expectations and a higher level of confidence in our potential grantees.

We must continue to be willing to shift out of our own comfort zone and capture opportunities in a new and different way. There is a fine line for foundations between protecting their existence and accomplishing their mission. The Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina and other foundations must be proactive and strike the perfect balance between our missions and long-term survival. We understand the complexities of this situation and that a lot of other people and organizations are effected by our decisions. The Sisters of Charity Foundation will continue to be a foundation of mission and purpose. That is our first and most important priority. Survival is important too, and we are putting the necessary tools in place to insure that a fine balance is reached both for 2010 and long into the future.


Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina

Monday, March 23, 2009

What is the profile of today's leader?

The discussion around leadership and what it takes to be a good leader occurs every single day. What are the qualities and expectations of today’s leaders verse those in the past?

First, we must recognize that we live in a very different world today. There are many challenges facing today’s leaders that were not “in play” even five years ago. Jobs are being outsourced, technology and information are instantly accessible and competition is no longer “down the street,” but it is worldwide.


So, leaders today in both the nonprofit and for profit sector have to deal with a lot of variables. For example, raising money or making revenue on the Internet has become a fascinating phenomenon. Leaders have to be much more sophisticated and technologically savvy individuals.


However, leaders today do not have to be a lot different in other ways. There are certain core qualities that are needed to be a successful leader no matter where you are leading and what decade you are leading in.


Here are my top ten core qualities of a leader of an organization:


1. Leaders must build trust with their staff and board or they will never be able to lead at the maximum level.


2. Leaders must be extraordinary communicators. They must communicate effectively with individuals, internal and external stakeholders.

3. Leaders should be humble leaders and, as my grandmother would say, never get “too big for their britches.” Lead by example and knowledge and not by using a heavy hand. Always be fair and sensitive to others.

4. A leader does not spend his or her time being consumed with managing processes and systems. That is management. A leader sees the big picture and provides the strategic thinking needed to take the organization to a different level.

5. Leadership is a combination of ever changing and moving parts. A leader must be flexible, adaptable and accepting of change.

6. A good leader does not have all the answers. There are a lot of great ideas and bright minds that can give great advice and make useful suggestions.

7. A good leader must be willing to get down in the trenches and understand the organization from the ground up. There should be no job too big or too small for a good leader.

8. A good leader should be consistent in their demeanor, attitude and style.

9. A good leader needs to be a good listener. We all grow from listening and learning, no matter who is talking.

10. The leader must always be unselfish and put the mission first. It should never be about the individual leader but that leader is a conduit to success within the overall organization.



Tom Keith is the president of the Sisters of Charity Foundation of South Carolina.